There's nothing quite like a grilled cheese sandwich, especially with butter on top. But what if you're trying to watch your figure, or you're just out of butter? No problem! You can still make delicious grilled cheese without using any butter at all. You have 5 options to make grilled cheese without the butter. Just follow these simple steps.
Jump to:
What happens if you don't put butter on grilled cheese?
If you don't put butter on your grilled cheese, you may find that the cheese doesn't melt as well or that the bread doesn't get as crispy. Additionally, the flavor of the grilled cheese may be affected since butter adds richness and depth of flavor. Ultimately, it's up to you whether or not to add butter to your grilled cheese, but know that it may impact the overall result.
How to make grilled cheese without butter?
It's easy to make a delicious grilled cheese without using butter - all you need is some good, old-fashioned creativity. You can use several other things that will make your sandwich even better.
Here are some of my favorites.
1 Mayonnaise
If you're looking for cheesy grilled cheese without any dairy, try using Mayonnaise instead of butter. Mayo might seem odd, but it's a great alternative to butter for grilled cheese. It's easy to spread and adds a nice depth of flavor to the sandwich. Plus, it helps keep the bread from getting too soggy.
The mayo will help the bread to be brown and crisp up nicely. I love using Mayonnaise in my grilled cheese because it adds a nice creaminess and depth of flavor. Just spread it on the bread like you would butter and continue with your recipe.
2 Olive oil
Olive oil is another great option for grilled cheese. The main reason is that it has a higher smoke point than butter, which means it can withstand high heat without burning. In making grilled cheese, this is crucial because you want to ensure the outside of your bread gets nice and crispy without burning the cheese on the inside.
It also has a nice flavor that complements the cheese and helps keep the bread from sticking to the pan. Simply brush a thin layer of oil on one or both slices of bread, then top with your favorite fillings and grill as usual.
3 Spreadable cheese (such as cream cheese)
In place of butter, cream cheese is a great alternative for grilled cheese because it is lower in saturated fat and has no cholesterol. Additionally, cream cheese provides a creamy texture and rich flavor that compliments the taste of the cheese and bread.
The cream cheese will not create the same crispy exterior. However, it will add a delicious creaminess to the sandwich that's far creamier and tangier than the classic version. So, if you're looking for a grilled cheese that is slightly different but just as delicious, give this version a try! It might not be traditional, but it's delicious.
To make a grilled cheese without butter:
- Start by spreading cream cheese on each side of your bread.
- Then, add your favorite cheese to the center of the sandwich and top it with another slice of bread.
- Cook the sandwich on a griddle or pan over medium heat until the cheese melts and the bread is golden brown.
- Serve immediately and enjoy!
Note: Use a light hand, so the bread doesn't get too greasy. You can also experiment with other spreads, such as pesto or tapenade.
4 Shredded cheese
It is a grilled cheese sandwich clad in lacy, crispy cheese instead of buttery bread. Why is that? Well, let's say that it's a texture thing. The cheese gets all crispy and lacy, as a grilled cheese should be, but the bread stays sturdy since there's no butter to soak into it.
The cheese creates a barrier between the bread and the skillet, resulting in an evenly toasted sandwich with nary a burnt spot. It also adds flavor.
5 Non-stick cooking spray
This is my go-to method when I'm in a hurry or don't have any other options. Just spray the bread lightly with a non-stick cooking spray and continue with your recipe.
Why use the non-stick cooking spray? For starters, it's a lot less messy. You don't have to worry about spreading the butter evenly, and you don't have to worry about it melting and making a mess.
Plus, the non-stick cooking spray provides just enough lubrication to prevent the bread from sticking to the pan while also helping the bread to brown evenly.
Read:
Why do you need butter for grilled cheese?
Grilled cheese is traditionally spread with butter. The purpose of the butter is twofold: it adds flavor and helps create a crispy, golden-brown exterior.
There's nothing wrong with butter, but a different fat can do a better job with crispiness.
Butter's low smoke point means it's more likely to burn on the pan and doesn't create as crisp of a crust. Conversely, Mayonnaise has a high smoke point and will give you a nice crispy edge. It also adds a bit of tanginess to the sandwich.
If you don't want to use mayo, you can also use olive oil, avocado oil, or even ghee. Whichever fat you choose, spread it evenly on both slices of bread, so your grilled cheese doesn't dry.
Which is better, mayo or butter, for grilled cheese
Which is better, mayo or butter, for grilled cheese? Over the years, this has been a contentious issue. Some say mayo is better because it doesn't burn as easily as butter, giving the sandwich a creamier texture. Others say butter is better because it adds flavor and crispy edges to the bread.
Read:
So, which is better? The answer may surprise you.
Butter makes uniformly browned sandwiches easier, and mayonnaise results in crispier cheese and a moister sandwich. So, in the end, it is really up to your personal preference. Go for the butter if you want an easy grilled cheese with evenly browned toast. If you are looking for a crispy cheese sandwich or one that is a little moister, mayo is the way to go!
Mayonnaise has a higher smoke point than butter, meaning it can withstand higher temperatures before starting to burn. More importantly, the texture will be crispier, and the bread will not dehydrate.
Have you ever left your grilled cheese on the stove too long for the butter to turn brown and smoke? With Mayonnaise, this never happens! The worst that will happen is your sandwich will be a little more well-done than intended.
Prolonged exposure to heat will result in the bread becoming less palatable. You can avoid that by spreading mayo on each slice of bread and then adding the cheese. This will help to insulate the bread and prevent it from drying out.
Mayo also helps to distribute the cheese over the surface of the bread evenly. If you have ever made a grilled cheese with just butter, you know that the cheese tends to clump up in one area while other parts of the bread are cheese-less. This is because the butter can't coat the bread evenly, resulting in patches of dry bread.
Tips for making grilled cheese without butter
1 Keep the heat low and cover: Cook your sandwich on low heat and cover it while cooking. It allows the cheese to melt slowly and evenly, so you don't have to worry about it burning or getting too crispy.
2 Quality bread is essential: Choose good quality bread that will hold up to low heat and not get too soggy. A thick sliced white bread or sourdough are both excellent options.
3 Slice thinly: Half-inch slices will do. Any thinner and the cheese won't have enough time to melt; any thicker and it won't be easy to flip.
4 Choose your cheese wisely: A sharp cheddar or Gruyere works well on grilled cheese sandwiches without butter. The sharper the cheese, the less butter you'll need. Good melting cheese is vital for a gooey grilled cheese.
5 Use mayo instead of butter: Grilled cheese sandwiches taste great with mayo. It has a similar consistency and will help your sandwich hold together.
6 Add some acidity: A little acidity will brighten the flavors in your grilled cheese without butter. Try adding a few slices of tomato or a drizzle of balsamic vinegar.
7 Don't forget the extras: A little bit of Dijon mustard or a sprinkle of freshly ground black pepper can take your sandwich to the next level.
8 Be patient: Don't rush the process! Slow and steady wins the race when it comes to grilled cheese without butter.
Grilled cheese is one of those comfort foods that everyone loves. It is simple yet so satisfying. And with this method, you can enjoy delicious grilled cheese without using any butter. So, go ahead and give it a try! You may be surprised at how good it is.
Can mayonnaise make your grilled cheese better?
The perfect grilled cheese sandwich seems simple. However, getting the right balance of crunchy bread, melty cheese, and gooeyness can be tricky—and butter plays a vital role. But what if we told you that Mayonnaise could be the secret ingredient to making your grilled cheese even better?
Simple ingredients make up Mayonnaise: oil, egg yolks, and an acid (vinegar or lemon juice). This combination gives mayo its thick, creamy texture, which can help add heft and creaminess to your grilled cheese. And since Mayonnaise is already emulsified (blended), it can help to distribute fat evenly and prevent your bread from getting greasy.
So, what can you do to prevent a barely toasted cheese melt or burnt sandwich with still-cold cheddar cheese?
- First, use good quality bread—slices thick enough to hold up to the mayo without getting soggy.
- Next, spread the mayo on your bread slices on the inside and outside surfaces for even coverage and flavor.
- Finally, cook your sandwich on medium-low heat until the cheese is melted and bubbly and the bread is golden brown and toasty.
Why is mayo better for grilled cheese?
Some say mayo creates a nicer texture and flavor in the grilled cheese sandwich. It also doesn't burn as easily as butter, so you can get a nice crispy exterior without worrying about the inside being dry.
Contrary to butter, a fat that burns quickly, mayo has a high smoke point. This means that it can help to insulate your bread and prevent burning, giving you more control over the cooking process.
Apart from saving you time, using Mayonnaise can take less of your time to spread than butter due to its smooth texture (essential when using white, soft bread). All you need is a thin layer on each slice of bread, which means no more painstakingly trying to butter each side of your sandwich evenly!
And most of all, it's all about the taste. Butter's rich creaminess can sometimes overpower the delicate flavors of your cheese, while Mayonnaise allows them to shine through. Due to its light and tangy flavor, Mayonnaise can add a new dimension to your grilled cheese.
If you're looking for an even richer grilled cheese, try using Mayonnaise instead of half the butter in your recipe. This will give you all the butter flavor with the added creaminess of Mayonnaise—a winning combination!
Is grilled cheese good with provolone?
Yes, grilled cheese is good with provolone. Cheese of this type is often used in its preparation. Provolone gives the sandwich a nice flavor and a creamy texture. Why is provolone good to use with grilled cheese?
The pros of using provolone in grilled cheese include the following:
- It has a strong, distinct flavor that can stand up to being melted and grilled.
- It has a creamy texture that makes for a delicious sandwich.
- It melts well, so getting that perfect grilled cheese consistency is easy.
You can use other cheeses for grilled cheese, including mozzarella, cheddar, and Swiss. Butter is not necessary for grilled cheese, but it does make the sandwich more flavorful. You can use Mayonnaise or olive oil if you are trying to avoid butter.
How can I add flavor to my grilled cheese?
1 One way to flavor your grilled cheese is to use flavored butter. You can find flavored butter at most grocery stores or make your own by adding herbs and spices to regular butter.
2 Another way to add flavor is to use a combination of cheeses in your sandwich. Why is that? The answer is simple: different cheeses have different flavors. Combining cheeses allows you to create grilled cheese with a more complex flavor than if you only used one cheese. Some good cheese combinations for grilled cheese include cheddar and Swiss, cheddar and Gruyere, and provolone.
3 Flavored bread can add even more flavor to your grilled cheese. Many types of flavored bread are available, including garlic bread, herb bread, and onion bread. You can also make your own by adding spices or herbs to regular bread dough before baking it.
4 Finally, add toppings to your grilled cheese to give it even more flavor. Get creative and experiment with different flavor combinations to find your perfect grilled cheese! Some good options include ham, bacon, tomato, avocado, or fried egg.
What kind of cheese makes the best-grilled cheese sandwich?
There are a lot of different types of cheese that you could use for your grilled cheese sandwich, but some of the most popular choices include cheddar, Swiss, and Gruyere. Each type of cheese has its own unique flavor that can add something special to your sandwich.
- Cheddar cheese is your best bet if you want a classic grilled cheese sandwich. This type of cheese has a sharp, bold flavor that goes great with crispy bread.
- Swiss cheese is another good option for a grilled cheese sandwich. It has a milder flavor than cheddar, but it still has enough flavor to stand out.
- Gruyere is a good choice if you want a grilled cheese sandwich that is extra cheesy. This type of cheese melts well, making your sandwich nice and gooey.
Bottom line:
Ultimately, the best type of cheese for your grilled cheese sandwich is the one you think tastes the best. There are many different types of cheese to choose from, so experiment until you find the perfect one for your sandwich.
What is the best bread for grilled cheese?
This question does not have one definitive answer, as many types of bread can be used for this dish. Many different types of cheese can be used, depending on personal preference. Some people prefer denser bread, while others like a more fluffy option.
Whole-grain bread and low-fat cheese are good choices for those looking for a healthier option. There are also many variables to consider when making grilled cheese, such as the type of grill or pan used and the cooking time. Experimenting with different techniques is the best way to find what works best for you.
Some people swear by using sourdough bread, which has a slightly tangy flavor that goes well with the cheese. Others prefer a more traditional white bread, which is softer and easier to bite into.
Is it better to butter the pan or bread with grilled cheese?
Some people swear by buttering the pan, while others say it's better to butter the bread. There are pros and cons to both methods.
Buttering the pan ensures that the bread won't stick and also helps create a crispy outer crust. However, evenly distributing the butter can be difficult, making some areas greasy while others are dry.
Buttering the bread gives you more control over how much butter is used and helps create a more even heat distribution. However, it can make the bread more likely to stick to the pan.
So, which method is better? Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference. Try both ways and see which one you prefer!
What to eat with grilled cheese?
There are a variety of things that go well with grilled cheese. A simple grilled cheese sandwich can be made even better by adding a few key ingredients. Try adding some of the following to your next grilled cheese sandwich:
Bacon: Adding bacon to a grilled cheese sandwich is a classic way to upgrade the dish. The smoky flavor of bacon pairs perfectly with the melty cheese and crispy bread.
Tomato: A slice of fresh tomato or sun-dried tomatoes can add a lovely sweetness and acidity to your grilled cheese.
Pesto: A dollop of either store-bought or homemade pesto can infuse your grilled cheese with tons of flavor.
Fruit: Believe it or not, fruit goes surprisingly well with grilled cheese. Try adding a few slices of apple, pear, or even some dried fruit for a sweet and unique twist.
Jams and jellies: A grilled cheese is the perfect vehicle for enjoying your favorite jams and jellies. Go for something classic like grape jelly or strawberry jam, or get adventurous with more unique flavors like chutney or fig spread.
Herbs and spices: If you want to add savory flavor to your grilled cheese, try sprinkling on some dried herbs or spices. There are many options available, including oregano, basil, and thyme. You could also get creative with a spice blend like Italian seasoning or garlic powder.
- Sautéed mushrooms
- Sliced apple
- Caramelized onions
- Balsamic vinegar
- Hot sauce
- Fresh herbs (basil, oregano, thyme)
In addition to these delicious toppings, don't forget the classic sides that go well with grilled cheese. Try pairing your sandwich with a bowl of soup, some roasted potatoes, or a simple green salad. And, of course, no meal is complete without a cold glass of milk or a cup of hot coffee.
Bon appetite! There are endless possibilities when it comes to upgrading your grilled cheese sandwich. Get creative and experiment with different combinations of ingredients to find your perfect match.
What is the best thing to dip grilled cheese in?
There are many different ways to enjoy grilled cheese, but one of the most popular is to dip it in a delicious soup or sauce. Our favorites include tomato soup, ranch dressing, and honey mustard. What's your favorite way to enjoy grilled cheese? What to serve with sandwiches besides chips?
Is eating grilled cheese good for you?
Most people love grilled cheese because of its gooey, melty texture and classic flavor. And while it's true that grilled cheese isn't the healthiest meal out there, it can be a part of a healthy diet if you make a few smart choices.
Instead of using white bread, choose whole wheat or multigrain bread. This will add some extra fiber to your meal and make you feel fuller longer.
And instead of using processed cheese, opt for real cheese like cheddar, Swiss, or Gruyere. These cheeses not only taste better but they're also packed with calcium and other nutrients.
As for the butter, you can either use spray butter or margarine, or use olive oil for cooking your sandwich.
So, if you're looking for a delicious and healthy grilled cheese recipe, give this one a try!
Can you save a grilled cheese for later?
Yes, you can save a grilled cheese for later. Just wrap it in foil or plastic and place it in the fridge. It will last for up to three days. When ready to eat, simply reheat it in the oven at 350°F for 7-10 minutes or microwave.
Can you refrigerate grilled cheese?
If you want to keep your grilled cheese sandwich fresh, it is best to refrigerate it. You can store the sandwich in a resealable plastic bag or wrap it in aluminum foil. If you plan on eating the sandwich within two days, it will be fine stored in the fridge. Otherwise, you can freeze the sandwich for up to three months.
When ready to eat the sandwich, simply reheat it in the microwave or oven. If you reheat the sandwich in the microwave, wrap it in a paper towel to prevent it from getting soggy. For a crispy grilled cheese, reheat the sandwich in a skillet over low heat.
What's the best way to reheat a grilled cheese sandwich?
The best way to reheat a grilled cheese sandwich is in a toaster oven. Place the sandwich on a foil and heat it for about 10 minutes at 350 degrees.
You can also reheat the sandwich in a microwave, but be careful not to overcook it—Microwave the sandwich for about 30-second intervals on 50% power. Repeat the process until the sandwich is warmed through.
Another option is to reheat the sandwich in a skillet over low heat. This will give the bread a crispy texture. Just place the sandwich in the skillet and cook for a few minutes on each side or until the bread is crispy and the cheese is melted.
What goes with grilled cheese: Get creative.
1 If you're avoiding bread, you can still enjoy a delicious grilled cheese sandwich. Add a slice of roasted eggplant or zucchini with your favorite cheese and grill until the cheese is melted and bubbly.
2 For a fun twist on the classic grilled cheese, try using cookies instead of bread. Place two cookies side-by-side, then top with your favorite cheese and grill until the cheese is melted and bubbly.
3 If you're looking for a grilled cheese that's a little lighter on the calories, try using a thin slice of deli turkey or chicken instead of bread. Top the meat with your favorite cheese and grill until the cheese is melted and bubbly.
4 For a grilled cheese packed with flavor, try combining cheeses instead of just one. Mix your favorite shredded cheeses, then top with your favorite fillings and grill as usual.
5 Get creative with your grilled cheese fillings! In addition to the classic tomato soup, try adding in some chopped onion, peppers, or fruit for a sweet and savory twist.
6 If you're looking for a slightly more sophisticated grilled cheese, try using gourmet cheeses and bread. Choose your favorite combination of bread and cheese, then grill as usual.
Whichever option you choose, spread it on the bread before adding the cheese and grilling as usual. Enjoy!
How to Make Grilled cheese without the butter
Pin RecipeEquipments:
- griddle or pan
Ingredients:
- bread
- mayonnaise, olive oil, cream cheese, cooking spray, shredded cheese
Instructions:
Mayonnaise
- Mayo might seem odd, but it’s a great alternative to butter for grilled cheese. It’s easy to spread and adds a nice depth of flavor to the sandwich. Plus, it helps keep the bread from getting too soggy.The mayo will help the bread to brown and crisp up nicely. I love using Mayonnaise in my grilled cheese because it adds a nice creaminess and depth of flavor. Just spread it on the bread like you would butter and continue with your recipe.
Olive oil
- Olive oil is another great option for grilled cheese. The main reason is that it has a higher smoke point than butter, which means it can withstand high heat without burning. In making grilled cheese, this is crucial because you want to ensure the outside of your bread gets nice and crispy without burning the cheese on the inside.It also has a nice flavor that complements the cheese and helps keep the bread from sticking to the pan. Simply brush a thin layer of oil on one or both slices of bread, then top with your favorite fillings and grill as usual.
Spreadable Cheese (like cream cheese)
- In place of butter, cream cheese is a great alternative for grilled cheese because it is lower in saturated fat and has no cholesterol. Additionally, cream cheese provides a creamy texture and rich flavor that compliments the taste of the cheese and bread. The cream cheese will not create the same crispy exterior. However, it will add a delicious creaminess to the sandwich that’s far creamier and tangier than the classic version.
Shredded Cheese
- It is a grilled cheese sandwich clad in lacy, crispy cheese instead of buttery bread. Why is that? Well, let’s say that it’s a texture thing. The cheese gets all crispy and lacy, as a grilled cheese should be, but the bread stays sturdy since there’s no butter to soak into it. The shredded cheese creates a barrier between the bread and the skillet, resulting in an evenly toasted sandwich with nary a burnt spot. It also adds flavor.
Non-Stick cooking spray
- This is my go-to method when I’m in a hurry or don’t have any other options. Just spray the bread lightly with a non-stick cooking spray and continue with your recipe.Why use the non-stick cooking spray? For starters, it’s a lot less messy. You don’t have to worry about spreading the butter evenly, and you don’t have to worry about it melting and making a mess.
Notes:
Tips for making grilled cheese without butter
1 Keep the heat low and cover: Cook your sandwich on low heat and cover it while cooking. It allows the cheese to melt slowly and evenly, so you don’t have to worry about it burning or getting too crispy.2 Quality bread is essential: Choose good quality bread that will hold up to low heat and not get too soggy. A thick sliced white bread or sourdough are both excellent options.
3 Slice thinly: Half-inch slices will do. Any thinner and the cheese won’t have enough time to melt; any thicker and it won’t be easy to flip.
4 Choose your cheese wisely: A sharp cheddar or Gruyere works well on grilled cheese sandwiches without butter. The sharper the cheese, the less butter you’ll need. Good melting cheese is vital for a gooey grilled cheese.
5 Use mayo instead of butter: Grilled cheese sandwiches taste great with mayo. It has a similar consistency and will help your sandwich hold together. 6 Add some acidity: A little acidity will brighten the flavors in your grilled cheese without butter. Try adding a few slices of tomato or a drizzle of balsamic vinegar.
7 Don’t forget the extras: A little bit of Dijon mustard or a sprinkle of freshly ground black pepper can take your sandwich to the next level.
8 Be patient: Don’t rush the process! Slow and steady wins the race when it comes to grilled cheese without butter.
Please note that all nutrition information are just estimates. Values will vary among brands, so we encourage you to calculate these on your own for most accurate results.
